Natural Beauty and Wonder

I am departing for today from my usual focus on health IT to write about the absolutely stunning beauty of the region that I am blessed to call home. I love the City of The Dalles and am so grateful to live in this gorgeous part of the country.


The Dalles with Mount Hood looming over

The Columbia River Gorge has so much to offer it is truly incredible. Whether you like hiking, wind surfing, rock climbing, skiing or just sitting watching the wildfowers bloom this place has everything.

View up the Columbia River Gorge

It is easy to find meaningful use for the amazing creation spread out all around. My wife and I love to go on adventures and never run out of things to do. I really do love it here and if you ever get a chance to visit you will find an amazing place and some really wonderful people.

Federal government is beginning to tax our patients

The Senate Finance Committee (SFC) released an options paper available here to explore ways to fund healthcare reform. It includes a wide variety of changes in the Medicare and Medicaid programs, from reducing payment updates to different health care sectors to reducing geographic variations in spending. The panel is taking the approach that just about everybody is going to have to take a hit to fund expansion of coverage.

The committee will conduct a “walk-through” of the options at a closed-door meeting Wednesday, May 20, 2009. The panel is also looking at new taxes on everything from employer’s healthcare benefits and nonprofit hospitals to alcohol and sweetened beverages, among many approaches to funding a package that could cost well over $1 trillion over 10 years.

The American Hospital Association (AHA) has been protesting some of the proposed changes in Medicare payments to hospitals. The hospital association said that implementation of the committee’s provisions on value-based purchasing, payment “bundling” and readmissions “would result in payment cuts to an already underfunded Medicare payment system.” While the AHA is certainly looking out for the interests of its members, there is a lot ot their argument.

The SFC will consider changes in Medicare out-of-pocket spending requirements to protect beneficiaries against catastrophic expense while at the same time require some minimal level of cost-sharing so that supplemental “Medigap” policies do not block beneficiaries from some sensitivity to the costs of using multiple services.

The options paper says that market basket adjustments for certain fee-for-service providers may be required to be adjusted “by some or all of the expected productivity gains as a way to improve the accuracy of Medicare payments.”

Cuts in Medicare payments for imaging are also on the table. The current method assumes that imaging machines are operated 50 percent of the time — but assuming a higher use rate would lower payments for advanced imaging technology while raising payments for other types of physician services. Another option would be to establish an expert panel to help the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services adjust payments “for potentially misvalued physician services,” the options paper states.

The paper also contemplates changes in funding for graduate medical education and “DSH” payments, meant to compensate hospitals that treat a disproportionate share of poor people. In fiscal 2009, Medicare DSH spending will total $10.1 billion and $9.1 billion in Medicaid, the paper notes.

The SFC report also suggests limiting the amount that workers can contribute to flexible spending accounts -- tax-free accounts workers use to pay for prescriptions and other medical expenses -- or possibly eliminating them altogether. Nonprofit hospitals that don't provide enough charitable care or meet other requirements would pay new taxes.

One thing that is important to remember in all of the options on funding is that hospitals and healthcare plans don’t pay taxes – people do. Any tax is ultimately paid by real living, breathing humans. So a tax on hospitals and healthcare providers is really a tax on patients. And the politicians already are beginning to tax our patience…

Bacteria Communication

Did you know that bacteria can actually communicate with each other? Bonnie Bassler, a microbiologist at Princeton, has discovered how bacteria communicate with each other and describes how they use chemical molecules and enzymes to communicate. Her research focused on the molecular mechanisms that bacteria use for intercellular communication.

She found a gene these bacteria use to sense whether they are part of a dense or sparse population of bacteria -- for example, whether they are living in the human body, as opposed to a puddle of water. And she discovered that more common and more dangerous bacteria have the same gene.

The gene could become a valuable tool to drug developers looking for new ways to attack bacteria that are becoming increasingly resistant to current treatments. In some cases, bacteria only start emitting the toxins that cause disease after they multiply and develop into a dense population.


Bassler found this molecular signal after years of studying certain luminescent bacteria that are widespread in oceans but are harmless to people. Her work focuses on figuring out how and why two species, called Vibrio harveyi and Vibrio fischeri, emit a blue glow.


In a petri dish, the arrow contains a mutant form of V. harveyi. On the left is a patch of E. coli that causes intestinal infections; on the right is Salmonella; in the middle, above and below the stem of the arrow, is a lab strain of E. coli that has lost its ability to harm people. In the dark (bottom photo), V. harveyi glows in the presence of the two pathogenic bacteria but not the harmless one.

She explains her work on her website here and in the video below:


HIT Standards Committee Meeting

The HIT Standards Committee meeting met this morning. I have the transcript posted here on Wordpress you can also see the Twitter stream and particpate in the discussion. Please feel free to comment on the meeting here on this blog as well. I am enjoying seeing the reaction to the beginning of this important work through blog postings, Twitter, email and other conversations.

Join the conversation...

Earlier this year I read a post from John Halamka's Blog that got me very interested in social networking for business purposes. I already had a Facebook account, an old out of date LinkedIn and Plaxo accounts, but I was intrigued at the possibilities to use this platform as a way to rapidly connect with others interested in healthcare information technology and healthcare reform. Up to that point I had mostly used Facebook as a personal space to connect with close friends and family (I still reserve it for mainly that purpose - my wife and I share the same page) I started exploring the features of LinkedIn and Plaxo and have recently opened a Twitter account.

LinkedIn and Plaxo are great ways to network with other professionals in your field. I know people who have found both jobs and excellent employees using these social media sites. There groups that you can join which will help you connect with like-minded people. All 500 corporations of the Fortune 500 are represented on LinkedIn. You might be amazed at the connections you can make. Check out the LinkedIn Blog to learn more about these powerful tools.

I have found Twitter to be a very powerful tool for real-time communication and an amazing way to connect with people, events and information from all over the world. I have kept my focus completely on health IT. I don't think there are many people wanting to know my adventures in dog walking or my recent struggle with pizza addiction ;-) You can see my latest posts on the left of this page and follow me on Twitter. If you open a new Twitter account a good primer is found on the
Wall Street Journal web site. There is also a great article on Healthcare Informatics web site.

The Obama administration has been using Twitter and Facebook. Now almost every federal government agency has an account. The recent HIT Policy Committee had interesting coverage on Twitter from
the #HITpol hashtag. There will be more coverage for the Standards committee on Friday at this site. As the flow of information intensifies over 'meaningful use' of an EHR, and the dollars start to flow from ARRA, Twitter can be a great tool to keep in touch with developments, make contacts, and join in the discussion. Together, we can do this thing...

Being open and sharing

I think the talk below by Tim Berners-Lee has philosophical ramifications for healthcare. One of the greatest problems with 'meaningful use' of EHRs is interoperability. We need to consider how we can best securely share data and develop open standards that work.

20 years ago, Tim Berners-Lee invented the World Wide Web. For his next project, he's building a web for open, linked data that could do for numbers what the Web did for words, pictures, video: unlock our data and reframe the way we use it together.

In the 1980s, scientists at CERN were asking themselves how massive, complex, collaborative projects could be orchestrated and tracked. Tim Berners-Lee, then a contractor, answered by inventing the World Wide Web. This global system of hypertext documents, linked through the Internet, brought about a massive cultural shift ushered in by the new tech and content.

Berners-Lee is now director of the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), which maintains standards for the Web and continues to refine its design. Recently he has envisioned a "Semantic Web" -- an evolved version of the same system that recognizes the meaning of the information it carries. He is also a senior researcher at MIT's Computer Science and AI Lab.





Data is relationships!

Hugging data leads to closed data silos. Of course, privacy requires tight controls, but standards need to be as open as possible so that when data needs to be shared there is a common framework to link data. Without open standards there could be no World Wide Web. Try to imagine life without an Internet...

Medicare and Social Security Going Broke

As we see the developments in Social Security and Medicare Trust Funds a few thoughts come to mind...

What Are the Trust Funds?

Congress established the trust funds in the U.S. Treasury to account for all program income and disbursements. Social Security and Medicare taxes, premiums, and other income are credited to the funds.

How big are Social Security and Medicare?

Social Security is currently 4.4% of GDP. Medicare is currently 3.2% of GDP.

When do these entitlements start paying out more than they bring in?

In the case of Social Security, 2016. In the case of Medicare, today. Medicare is already losing money.

There are actually four separate trust funds. For Social Security, the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) Trust Fund pays retirement and survivors benefits, and the Disability Insurance (DI) Trust Fund pays disability benefits. (The two trust funds are often considered on a combined basis designated OASDI.) For Medicare, the Hospital Insurance (HI) Trust Fund pays for inpatient hospital and related care. The Supplementary Medical Insurance (SMI) Trust Fund comprises two separate accounts: Part B, which pays for physician and outpatient services, and Part D, which covers the prescription drug benefit.


Medicare Cost and Non-Interest Income by Source as a Percent of GDP


Concern about the long-range financial outlook for Medicare and Social Security often focuses on the exhaustion dates for the HI and OASDI Trust Funds—the time when projected finances under current law would be insufficient to pay the full amount of scheduled benefits. A more immediate issue is the growing burden that the programs will place on the Federal budget well before the trust funds are exhausted.

The Medicare Modernization Act (2003) requires that the Board of Trustees determine each year whether the annual difference between program outlays and dedicated revenues (the bottom four layers of the chart above) exceeds 45 percent of total Medicare outlays within the first 7 years of the 75-year projection period. In effect, the law sets a threshold condition that signals that a trust fund's dedicated financing is inadequate and/or that general revenue financing of Medicare is becoming excessive.


Projected OASDI and HI Tax Income Shortfall plus the 75-Percent General Fund Revenue Contribution to SMI
(Percentage of GDP)



The combined difference grows each year, so that by 2016, net revenue flows from the general fund would total $369 billion (1.8 percent of GDP). The positive amounts that begin in 2016 for OASDI, and started in 2008 for HI, initially represent payments the Treasury must make to the trust funds when assets are depleted to help pay benefits in years prior to exhaustion of the funds. Neither the redemption of trust fund bonds, nor interest paid on those bonds, provides any new net income to the Treasury, which must finance redemptions and interest payments through some combination of increased taxation, reductions in other government spending, or additional borrowing from the public.

The chart above shows that the difference between outgo and dedicated payroll tax and premium income will grow rapidly in the 2010-30 period as the baby-boom generation reaches retirement age. These Trust Funds are not to be trusted... This is the greatest Ponzi scheme ever!