#Gov20 - Let the sunshine in

The historic swearing in of Supreme Court Justice Sotomayor is significant not only in the fact that she is the first Hispanic to serve on the Supreme Court, but also this is the first time that cameras have been allowed in the court for this ceremony. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts swore Sotomayor in twice, the first in a private ceremony as stipulated in the U.S. Constitution and a second time before television cameras, friends and family, a first in Supreme Court history.

The various Justices have held differing opinions on whether camers in the courtroom are appropriate. While he was still Supreme Court justice, David Souter (who is replaced by Sonia Sotomayor) discouraged any attempts to broadcast Supreme Court proceedings. He used the "camel's nose" theory fearing that once they had even the slightest amount of access, the media would soon gain full access to Court proceedings. Justice Souter once told a House Appropriations subcommittee, “that I can tell you the day you see a camera come into our courtroom, it’s going to roll over my dead body.” Justice Sotomayor is of a different opinion.

Chief Justice Roberts has signaled that he may not oppose televised court proceedings. Roberts said during his confirmation hearings that he had an open mind about the issue of cameras in the Supreme Court, a statement that gave advocates new hope after the late Chief Justice Warren Burger's "over my dead body" opposition and his successor William Rehnquist's less vehement but still unyielding distaste for the idea.

“Justice Souter going off the court means a vocal opponent is gone,” said C-SPAN founder and CEO Brian Lamb, adding that Chief Justice John Roberts may not have wanted to press the issue with Souter there. C-SPAN has long wanted to broadcast proceedings of the court and they may some day now get their wish. “The chief justice who has his hand on the gavel can control any kind of rambunctiousness in which lawyers might want to show off. The public would benefit by seeing this isn’t ‘Judge Judy,’” Lamb said. “The process of writing opinions will never be public. All we’re asking for is the public discussion for one hour. It’s in a public forum, and there’s only 80 of those a year.”

Justice Stephen Breyer, when questioned by Rep. John Culberson (who filmed the statement himself) during a House Appropriations subcommittee hearing.“On the one hand, of course it would help people see how in some of these difficult issues we struggle with them, as do you." On the other hand, he continued, “would they know that this is 2 percent of the matter, what they’re seeing, and would they, in fact, understand that most of what we do does not involve the two people in front of us, the lawyers on either side? It involves the 300 million people who are not there physically in the courtroom.” At the Aspen Ideas Festival Justice Stephen Breyer responded to a question about televising oral arguments at the Supreme Court (see video below). He spelled out the two sides position on the issue without giving any support to either position.



I think we will see the Supreme Court televised one day. I look forward to that day...

CTO of the USA comes to Silicon Valley

Aneesh Chopra spoke to technology thought leaders on his first visit to Silicon Valley this past Tuesday evening. He was appointed by the President as the nation’s first Chief Technology Officer, with the mandate to promote technological innovation to help the country meet its most urgent priorities - from creating jobs and reducing health care costs to keeping our nation secure. Mr. Chopra spoke at the Computer History Museum in Mountain View at an event co-hosted by the Churchill Club, Center for Democracy & Technology, and TechNet.

He spoke about R&D collaboration, infrastructure, and education in the 21st Century. The USA is very advanced in technology, but our technological savvy "has not translated to global competitiveness and our public policy. It should be just as easy to get things going in government as in your personal life with things like Facebook or Twitter," said Chopra.

In one of the slides Chopra used President Obama is viewing the new Federal IT Dashboard, a new website enabling federal agencies and the general public to view details of federal information technology investments. "That's my boss," Chopra said with a chuckle.

Mr. Chopra gave a brilliant performance as you can see below. He is obviously very well qualified for this position, and I am glad that we have such capable hands at the helm with the siginificant challenges we are facing.


What #HealthReform will look like II

Cost and quality are intertwined and very important issues in any healthcare reform plan. With medical malpractice reform off the table, reducing costs will require administrative simplification and reimbursement changes. We will need to move from paying for volume to paying for quality. The implementation of a Medical Home Model can help with chronic disease management and provide better continuity of care, while also ultimately lowering costs. We should create increased incentives for health savings accounts, with a mix of public and private coverage available. Involving the patient as much as possible in healthcare decisions (and giving them a financial stake) will be an important component if reform is to be successful.


Attempts at administrative simplification (remember HIPAA) is no guarantee that costs will be lowered, but streamlining billing codes and practices can do a lot. We can save billions of dollars by cutting through the administrative red tape, according to a recent report released by the Healthcare Administrative Simplification Coalition, or HASC. Founded by the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American Health Information Management Association and the Medical Group Management Association, HASC is a partnership of organizations committed to reducing the administrative costs and complexity of health care. The report "Bringing Better Value: Recommendations to Address the Costs and Causes of Administrative Complexity in the Nation's Healthcare System," claims that about 25% of healthcare costs (approximately $2 trillion) go toward administrative functions, such as billing and payment tasks. "These wasted health care dollars could be much better spent on ensuring that all Americans have access to high-quality health care," said Douglas Henley, M.D. "If we don't work toward reducing administrative complexity in our health care system, we'll continue to waste both time and money."


The healthcare cost explosion has not been accompanied by clear and measurable quality improvements, and we are going to eventually need to change the way we pay for care. We should try to stop paying based on the number of procedures and instead pay based on results. Tying payments to outcomes not only saves money, but improves quality. Minnesota has implemented an innovative program called QCARE, for Quality Care and Rewarding Excellence. QCARE identifies quality measures, sets aggressive outcome targets for providers, makes comparable measures transparent to the public, and changes the payment system to reward quality rather than quantity. These types of innovations will be required on a national scale.


But cost reforms won’t help much if we don’t have more doctors working in the fields where we need them, such as primary care, pediatrics, and behavioral/mental health. Physician workforce enhancement programs will provide greater access, lower costs, and higher quality care. When doctors are not overloaded, stressed out and under-reimbursed thay will provide much better care.


Health information technology will also lower costs and improve quality. Most providers lack the information systems necessary to coordinate patient’s care, share necessary information, monitor compliance, and measure and improve performance. Most other industries have lowered costs and improved quality through investments in information technology, yet healthcare has been stuck. It is time to pull our healthcare system into the 21st century. Health IT helps with prevention by scanning patient records for risk factors and by recommending appropriate preventive services, such as vaccinations and screenings. Health IT can also assist in effective chronic disease management by helping to identify patients in need of tests or other services, and ensuring consistent recording of results. Patients using remote monitoring systems can transmit information directly from their homes to their providers, allowing a quick response to potential problems. I think that all of the efforts at reform are going to need to be tied to a robust national health information network.


I like the quote from President Franklin D. Roosevelt: “In regard to every problem that arises, there are counselors who say, ‘Do nothing’; other counselors who say, ‘Do everything.’ Common sense dictates an avoidance of both extremes. I say to you: ‘Do something’; and when you have done that something, if it works, do it some more; and if it does not work, then do something else.”

What #HealthReform will look like

Gazing into my crystal ball I am getting some idea of what the final healthcare reform product from Congress will be. The devil is in the details, and there are still many to be worked out, but we can see some broad areas where I feel safe making predictions. The areas of coverage, access, costs and quality will be addressed (albeit probably not comprehensively). There are different aspects of each of these areas which overlap, and a change in one area of the healthcare system will have effects throughout the system. Today I will look at coverage and access.

In the area of coverage, we will see a public option plan. Many decry this as a government take over of the healthcare system. But as Paul Krugman said, "Getting the government involved in health care wouldn’t be a radical step: the government is already deeply involved, even in private insurance." The government already covers about 100 million Americans. Medicare dominates the market, stifles competition, and sets arbitrary and unfair pricing standards. Many want a single-payer system. When I met with Senator Merkley yesterday I asked him directly did he support a single-payer system and he said, "Yes I do, but that will never happen this time around." I tend to agree. The momentum is certainly against this option, so a compromise will be the public option plan. Many believe that this is a trojan horse to eventually implement a single-payer system, and for some that is certainly the plan. Rep. Barney Frank admitted that a public option is the best strategy to move towards single-payer because they do not have the votes to pass it now. If it was all or nothing for single-payer right now, there would be no health reform passed. It would kill the deal. We will see a multi-payer universal enrollment system, much like what they have in Switzerland, Japan, the Netherlands, Ireland, and Australia.

With regards to access, by adding coverage for millions of additional patients we will seriously exacerbate the shortage of primary care physicians (family doctors, general internists, geriatricians and pediatricians). of about 50,000 which we already face. The argument that these folks already get healthcare via the emergency room does not mean that we will have adequate resources for them to find family primary care physicians to care for them. Since it takes eight to 12 years to educate and train a primary care physician we have a steep climb to fill the gap. In the Physicians' Foundation survey of 270,000 primary care physicians, virtually all of those now practicing in the U.S., revealed that 54 percent planned to retire or see fewer patients within the next few years; 60 percent said they would not recommend medicine as a career for their children; and 36 percent said Medicare does provide adequate reimbursement. We are already facing a crisis, and expanding coverage will worsen the doctor shortage.

The health reform package will attempt to address these issues by establishing primary care based medical homes to coordinate and provide comprehensive care; cutting medical school debt for doctors promising to practice in underserved regions of the country; and funding to help expand the number of medical schools, the number of medical students in existing schools and the number of training programs for primary care residencies. This will be an expensive but necessary component of any successful reform efforts.

Later I will take a look at possible reform efforts in the area of cost and quality. One thing I will say is that it is unlikely that we will see any tort reform included. The political process is going into overdrive this summer, and there is going to be extensive lobbying pressure applied. Some of the more controversial elements (threats of a single-payer system, abortion, end of life counseling for seniors) will be removed as compromise takes place to buy votes in congress. Pork filler will be added and the end result will be a bloated, bureaucratic beast that may or may not make healthcare more affordable, accessible and higher quality for everyone.

Can CEOs help fix healthcare?

Two of the authors of "The Innovator's Prescription," Clayton Christensen and Jason Hwang, wrote a recent article in Wall Street Journal titled "How CEOs Can Help Fix Health Care" they put forth the proposition that American companies can turn high healthcare costs from a weakness into a strength. But they start with an admission that "High health care costs are one reason many of America's once-venerable corporations – like General Motors and Chrysler -- are struggling to compete globally." They go on to say:


Foreign firms rely on their governments to shoulder the burden of providing health care to employees; in the U.S., tough decisions about funding and managing healthcare has always fallen upon business leaders. However, rather than simply being a historical and cultural burden, this responsibility also creates the opportunity for remarkable innovation.

The idea makes some sense in a theoretical way, but to pursue the innovative opportunities the business would first have to be enabled to handle the current burden of providing health insurance. The article makes three basic recommendations:


We recommend executives make one or more of three innovative changes: 1) encourage employees to use nurse-staffed in-store health clinics for common ailments, 2) partner with integrated health systems like Kaiser Permanente, and 3) set up company-run clinics at corporate offices and plants.
Not all of these options are viable alternatives for most businesses, and some would find it hard to implement any of them. However, those businesses that can move towards these steps would be wise to take their advice or possibly suffer the fate of the auto industry. Healthcare reform is going to take innovation and cooperation from both the public and private sector, and corporations can not wait for Congress to address the crushing costs.

Lawrence H. Stiffman, Ph.D, MPH makes a case for Retail Clinics 2.o and promotes the idea that Retail clinics 2.0 could fulfill Public Health Service disease prevention mandates and guidance, partnering with manufacturers, PHRs like Google Health and Microsoft HealthVault, visiting nurses and local health departments, and schools to establish a new paradigm for a medical home model.

Christensen and Hwang say:


Retail clinics are basic health clinics staffed by nurses and located inside pharmacies and stores such as Wal-Mart, CVS and Walgreens. There are about 1,000 such sites in 37 states, according to a September 2008 article in the journal Health Affairs. Nurses deliver routine medical care for common ailments like a sore throat or ear infection. A typical visit costs one-third less than an urgent care clinic visit and three-quarters less than a visit to an emergency department, according to another article in Health Affairs that analyzed the costs to the insurance carrier.

Ninety percent of retail clinic visits are for 10 common complaints that constitute 18% of all visits to primary care doctors and 12% of visits to emergency rooms. So, the more employees visit retail clinics for these common problems, the more money companies will save.

Plus, retail clinics would help reduce the absenteeism related to the time it normally takes to schedule an appointment, see a doctor and fill a prescription. Retail clinics have made convenience a key part of their sales pitch by offering walk-in, no-wait visits in places where people already shop.


William Hazel, MD, a member of the American Medical Association's Board of Trustees, said retail-based clinics can "play a positive role if done properly, but they are not a substitute for a regular medical home," a term which describes the relationship built between a primary health care provider and her or his patients to help ensure all of the medical needs of patients are met.

The hard part is creating and staffing these new retail clinics (as well as the reaction from entrenched interests who might believe that this is an intrusion on their territory). The retail clinic trend is important in a nation with up to 40 million uninsured, any of whom could end up in an emergency room because without insurance or a "medical home," a simple sore throat turns into a costly hospital visit. Going to the local drugstore or other retail clinic to be diagnosed and treated for a sore throat or aching ear could become a typical healthcare scenario and would certainly be a disruptive innovation.

The article also delves into the thorny issue of fee-for-service reimbursement. Although pay-for-performance is already gaining more widespread use, the effects of this incentive system on physician response and healthcare outcomes are still unclear. What types of financial incentive strategies work best is also still undetermined. But I agree with the authors that the fee-for-service reimbursement system is not sustainable:

Next, employers must take aim at the fee-for-service reimbursement system, which is the most common method by which health insurance companies pay for medical services and which has fueled much of our skyrocketing healthcare costs. Fee-for-service rewards providers who are able to squeeze in more patient visits and perform more procedures. It encourages providers to profit from treating sickness, but not from maintaining the wellness of their patients.

Employers can help fix this flawed incentive structure by moving their employees away from health plans that offer little more than a telephone directory of independent contractors. The alternative is to partner with prepaid, integrated health systems like Kaiser Permanente, which serve as both insurer and care provider. These organizations are much more likely to deliver cost effective care that keeps their members well because these organizations are involved in both delivery and financing of care.


The high cost of healthcare must be addressed and innovations in methods of reimbursement will be key to achieving savings. California physicians given financial incentives to improve the quality of healthcare have made important changes designed to reduce costs, according to the results of a RAND Corporation study reported in the March/April issue of Health Affairs.

"Physician groups are responding to pay-for-performance programs by making practice changes and altering how they compensate physicians to reward quality, but health plans and purchasers say that those investments are not yet translating into substantial gains in quality," lead author Cheryl L. Damberg, PhD, a senior policy researcher at RAND in Santa Monica, California, said. "The true benefits of these programs may take more time to be realized and it is likely that investments in other quality efforts will be needed in addition to performance-based pay."

Health IT can help achieve these quality measures and promote further disruptive innovations. Using an Electronic Health Record connected via a Health Information Exchange is a first crucial step to any meaningful reform. Changes in reimbursement structure, quality measures, medical home models and expanding access will only be fully realized if we use all of the technology tools available.

Dr. Mehmet Oz at the Aspen Health Forum 2009

#AHF09 - Take 22 minutes to watch this video, it will be worth it...
Unlike medical and scientific conferences that confuse jargon with dialogue, the Aspen Health Forum is designed for clarity. Consistent with the Aspen Institute’s tradition of bringing together the leaders of industry, politics, finance and philanthropy, the forum focused on what thought leaders and other committed voices need to know about health today.
As he prepares to launch a new television series dedicated to our understanding of health and medicine, America's doctor, Dr. Mehmet Oz, speaks candidly about health care reform in America at the Aspen Health Forum 2009. This video below is well worth the 22 minutes:

Police release 911 call in Gates arrest

Cambridge police have released a copy of the 911 call and radio dispatches made during the controversial arrest of last week black Harvard scholar Henry Louise Gates Jr: